Cleveland Browns: Why Roll the Dice on Johnny Manziel when Tim Tebow is Available?( TKS David)

 
 

 

COMMENTARY | The Cleveland Browns are looking to make a name for themselves this offseason, that much seems sure.

The Browns’ reported infatuation with Texas A&M quarterback Johnny Manziel seems to prove that point. Cleveland’s front office is so in love with Manziel that it has been reported that the Browns are willing to trade up in the 2014 NFL Draft to acquire him.

All this is interesting, because talent-wise, many folks do not believe that Manziel is the most talented quarterback in the draft. He is almost certainly behind Louisville signal-caller Teddy Bridgewater from a talent standpoint, and Blake Bortles of Central Florida might be more NFL-ready than Manziel, as well.

Knowing this, one has to wonder why the Browns are so high on Manziel. It almost seems that Cleveland’s front office is more interested in style over substance, so to speak. It could also be that the notoriety that comes from having Manziel on the roster would help the Browns form the identity that they have lacked in recent years.

If that’s the case, then maybe the Browns should go a different route in acquiring the player that will give this franchise an identity, because there is certainly one free agent that could do that — Tim Tebow.

While Manziel presumably counts down the days to his likely top-five selection in the draft, Tebow is busy doing everything he can to prove that he still has what it takes to be a starting quarterback in the NFL. Tebow would give the Browns an identity for sure, and let’s face it, the risk that the Browns would be taking in signing him is far less than the risk associated with Manziel.

Acquiring Tebow would be far more cost-effective for the Browns, as they could sign him to a non-guaranteed contract. Manziel, on the other hand, would likely be guaranteed to make $20-plus million before ever playing a single down in the NFL.

Either player would bring a lot of national attention to the Browns, of that there is little doubt. Manziel or Tebow jerseys would both sell at a high rate, but in my opinion the Browns might be smarter to take their chances with a player that is older, wiser, and quite frankly might just want it more at this point.

Shaun Heidrick is a Yahoo Contributor who has followed the Cleveland Browns for over 25 years.

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
477 views

10 Responses to “Cleveland Browns: Why Roll the Dice on Johnny Manziel when Tim Tebow is Available?( TKS David)”

  1. Sage says:

    Manziel (sp) looks rather frail compared to Tebow. Don’t think he can hold up to punishment nearly as well as Tebow.

    • ck says:

      Sage: I believe you are correct b/c there is no comparison where T2 is concerned!!! Manziel is not in the same league imo character-wise or other-wise!!!

  2. steve says:

    Why? Because Manziel can throw…

    • ck says:

      That argument is obviously flawed due to all the games he has WON and he is a WINNER; I.E., BCS CHAMPIONSHIPS, NFL PLAYOFF, ETC.! BOY RU BLIND?!!

  3. GM says:

    While you can argue the merits of Manziel as he his not big but he can throw and that is one thing Tebow has proven he can not do. Do yourself a favor and look at all the stiffs that litter NFL rosters at QB. No Tebow which tells me nobody thinks he is an NFL QB. Manziel may be unproven in the NFL but a team selecting him has a chance for a franchise QB.

    I know that someone will point to Tebow’s record and his playoff win as PROOF that he is a QB but it would be the same as making the argument that Trent Dilfer is equal to Peyton Mannning because they have the same number of SB rings.

    Tebow would probably make a heck of an H-Back or fullback. Good luck with the Tebow quest.

    Buzzy Says : You must be Dave Caldwell the GM of the Jaguars

    • Brandi says:

      Watch out “GM”…Jimmy Haslam fired the first shot at your ilk. More are coming. Your breed’s days of walking over the Will of the Fans is coming to a long overdue end.

  4. andrea says:

    GM – Dilfer is a better QB than Peyton Manning – you forgot to mention Peyton has lost 3 Super Bowls.

    GM – I also remember Tebow won 7 regular season games for the Broncos in eleven games.

    Teams last year that in 16 games won less than 7

    Buffalo
    Cleveland
    Jacksonville
    Minnesota
    Tampa Bay
    Houston
    Oakland
    Washington
    Atlanta.

  5. shaztah says:

    The Brown’s are so messed up right now I wouldn’t want Tim to go there anyway. He needs stability. The Brown’s deserve a personality like Manziel. It will take him years to grow up and get his ego in check. Good luck with that. Just another SCAM Newton.

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPressDesigned by: best suv | Thanks to trucks, infiniti suv and toyota suv